She's Amish, and he's an Englisher.
Matt and Alice are thrust together when Matt's sister and brother-in-law pass away, leaving behind their baby girl. Matt and Alice are two drastically different individuals who must decide which one of them is better placed to adopt the baby.
When snowflakes are swirling outside, presents under the tree, and laughter ringing through the air, can these two rivals put aside their differences for the sake of the child?
This Christmas, could all their prayers be answered?