Farthest South & Other Stories

Starred review from January 15, 2021
Fairy tales and bedtime stories for those dark nights of the soul. The two stories bookending Rutherford's second collection find a father named Soren drawing from his imagination to ease his young sons toward sleep. Both stories become monstrously supernatural, pitting young boys against sea creatures who threaten to devour their souls. In "The Diver," the final story, Soren fears that his sons realize his tale has "gone off the rails" as a giant squid who flooded the hometown of two abandoned brothers battles a disembodied diver. And, yes, if this were a fable, it has likely lost its point, its moral. But it's indicative of Soren's mental state, as he fears that his life, his marriage, his family, and his home are all going off the rails. The elements of plot in these stories are often strange and scary--two foxes kidnap a human child to raise as their own, a mother succumbs to spiritual illness, a baby's illness is nightmarishly investigated at an impersonal hospital--and the contexts throughout are young families, young marriages, young children, and the perception of overwhelming threat facing them all. The stories they weave, which incorporate elements of memories, dreams, fears, and fables, don't necessarily provide comfort or even much in the way of resolution. They don't have a lesson except that people tell stories to seek order amid chaos, hope amid impending doom, a reason to keep going. The farthest-flung adventure is the title story, which finds a Norse grandfather, a talking penguin, and 25 children on an ill-fated expedition to the South Pole. "Enchantment, wonder...uncharted, limitless white," marvels the penguin. There are hints that the whole story is unfolding within the grandfather's mind or that the narrator is imagining what his grandfather is experiencing as he lies comatose for two months in the hospital. Yet each of these stories has that same white canvas, uncharted, to be filled. Stories that test the boundaries of the fictional imagination.

COPYRIGHT(2021) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.